There was a great series on NPR last week about young Americans moving away from religion. One of the points they made is that while many young people are moving to the left, organized religion is moving to the right. For the first time, the number of Protestants is seriously dipping. I think it’s time for liberal religious traditions (in my case I’m concerned about liberal Jewish movements) to make a compelling case. Here’s my stab at it.
It seems that to be a religious person today in the United States, one has to follow extremist leaders and their doctrines or focus on the positive aspects of religious communities and traditions while ignoring the rest. You don’t have to make that choice if you are part of a liberal Jewish movement. Liberal Judaism is a faith tradition not of either/or, but of both/and.
- We both accept scientific fact and believe the stories of our tradition contain existential truths.
- We are both intellectually curious and spiritually aware.
- We are energized and inspired by both change and tradition.
- We value and respect both individual needs and the needs of the community as a whole.
- We care about both universal causes including hunger and civil rights and have a high concern for Israel and Jews everywhere.
- We both embrace creative expression, learning and exploration, and we are supported by long-standing Jewish communal institutions.
Being both/and is not trying to be something for everyone. It is not wishy-washy. It is a philosophy for a progressive, integrated and modern Jewish community, one that adapts while still preserving its essential core. Judaism offers us a way to grapple with life’s most challenging and invigorating questions. It gives comfort where there is none. It pushes us to be better than we might. Our tradition is robust, and it is relevant to the issues we face today. The more people who seriously participate in its evolution, the stronger it becomes.
What would you change? Do you think people could get behind this? Whom do you know that is making a compelling case for liberal Judaism?